In The State Of Florida – Marissa Alexander Had A Gun Permit, Stood Her Ground, Did Not Shoot Or Kill Anyone and Faces 25 Years In Prison,Lincoln B. Alexander Jr on behalf of Marissa Alexander
Marissa Alexander Stood Her Ground – No One Was Injured or Murdered – She Faces 25 Years In Prison
Case No: 2010-CF-8579
Division: CR-G
April 3, 2012
Dear Supporters:
On August 1 2010, my premature baby girl, born nine days earlier, was in the Baptist South N.I.C.U. fighting for her life and I would too be fighting for my life in my own home against an attack from my husband.
My name is Marissa Alexander, I am a mother of three children, but at the present time, I am not able to be with them due to the following circumstances. I am currently sitting in the Pretrial Detention Facility in Jacksonville FL, Duval County awaiting a sentence for three counts of aggravated assault with a deadly weapon with no intent to harm. Before my life changed drastically on that August afternoon, I was in the perilous position of leaving an abusive relationship with my husband who has history of violence and documented domestic abuse towards women. Our history included one which required me to place an injunction for protection against violence and was active during the month of August 2010.
In an unprovoked jealous rage, my husband violently confronted me while using the restroom. He assaulted me, shoving, strangling and holding me against my will, preventing me from fleeing all while I begged for him to leave. After a minute or two of trying to escape, I was able to make it to the garage where my truck was parked, but in my haste to leave I realized my keys were missing. I tried to open the garage but there was a mechanical failure. I was unable to leave, trapped in the dark with no way out. For protection against further assault I retrieved my weapon; which is registered and I have a concealed weapon permit. Trapped, no phone, I entered back into my home to either leave through another exit or obtain my cell phone.
He and my two stepsons were supposed to be exiting the house thru the front door, but he didn’t leave. Instead he came into the kitchen that leads to the garage and realized I was unable to leave. Instead of leaving thru the front door where his vehicle was parked outside of the garage, he came into the kitchen by himself. I was terrified from the first encounter and feared he came to do as he had threatened. The weapon was in my right hand down by my side and he yelled, “Bitch I will kill you!”, and charged toward me. In fear and desperate attempt, I lifted my weapon up, turned away and discharged a single shot in the wall up in the ceiling. As I stood my ground it prevented him from doing what he threatened and he ran out of the home. Outside of the home, he contacted the police and falsely reported that I shot at him and his sons. The police arrived and I was taken into custody.
I was devastated and would continue to be for months following the incident. I had to appear in court all the way up until trial as I plead not guilty and know that I acted in self-defense. I believe my actions saved my life or prevented further harm, but preserved that of my husband who was completely irrational, extremely violent, and unpredictable that day.
Florida has a self-defense law and it includes the right to stand your ground. Below are the facts of my concern with the incorrect way the law was applied and ultimately the injustice in my case.
· The alleged victim, my husband, under sworn statement in November 2010, admitted he was the aggressor, threatened my life and was so enraged he didn’t know what he would do.
· The alleged victim, my husband, was arrested for domestic violence two times, once for abuse against me. The attack against me was so violent; I ended up in the hospital.
· Prior to my arrest, I told the office I was in fear for my life due to the prior violence against me. I also told the officer there was a domestic injunction in place to protect me against abuse from the alleged victim. This information was written in detail by the officer in my arrest report, but ignored for some unknown reason.
· In July of 2011, a hearing was held, where I along with the alleged victims testified as it relates to the stand your ground law and its immunity from prosecution.
· After the hearing, Judge Elizabeth Senterfitt denied my motion, citing that I could have exited the house thru the master bedroom window, front door, and/or sliding glass back door. The law specifically states: No duty to retreat.
· My attorney entered a standing objection on the record to the ruling and we proceeded to trial.
· During that time, Angela Corey, our State Attorney met with the alleged victims. I also along with my attorney met with Angela Corey, John Guy, and then prosecutor Christen Luikart. I justified my actions to them and the truth as I have told it has remained the same.
· Knowing our prior domestic abuse history, Angela Corey was hard pressed for the minimum mandatory, which provisions allow for prosecution to wave those stipulations. I was not guilty, nor did I believe that was fair and just under the circumstances. She also allowed for those same provisions in the State vs. Vonda Parker, same charges different circumstances which did not include self-defense.
· Florida uses a law commonly known as 10-20-life as a sentencing guideline when a felony takes place with the use of a weapon. Under this statute, my felony charge of aggravated assault with a deadly weapon without intent to harm carries a twenty year mandatory sentence.
· Stand your ground law has been applied in multiple recent incidents, the following is just a couple of incidents. Carl Kroppman Jr was allowed to use this law to avoid being arrested/charged during a road rage incident on the Buckman Bridge in Jacksonville, FL in August of 2011. Marqualle Woolbright of Ocala, FL avoided murder charges due to the stand your ground law when he shoot and killed someone.
I am a law abiding citizen and I take great pride in my liberty, rights, and privileges as one. I have vehemently proclaimed my innocence and my actions that day. The enigma I face since that fateful day I was charged through trial, does the law cover and apply to me too?
A step further and more importantly is in light of recent news, is justice for all include everyone, regardless of gender, race or aristocratic dichotomies. I simply want my story heard, reviewed and the egregious way in which my case was handled from start to finish serve as an eye opener for all and especially those responsible for upholding judicial affairs.
The threat that day was very real, imminent, and the battery on me occurred minutes before the decision I made to protect myself. That decision was a last resort, necessary and a reaction to the continued threat on my life. I am a believer that grace allowed for my response to be carried out in a non-lethal manner. This prevented the imminent threat and harm a non-fatal tactic, but not against an unknown attacker, rather my very own husband. That was by far the most difficult position to be in nine days after giving birth to a six week premature infant. My heart goes out for my two stepsons and always has had a hurt and sincere empathy for them being subjected innocently to that trauma.
The law states that I was justified in standing my ground and meeting force with force up to including deadly force, but political views and concerns states otherwise in the 4th circuit court.
So my last questions and valid concerns are what was I supposed to do that day and the stand your ground law who is it for?
Sincerely,
Lincoln B. Alexander Jr on behalf of Marissa Alexander
Marissa Alexander Stood Her Ground – No One Was Injured or Murdered – She Faces 25 Years In Prison
Marissa Alexander A Battered Woman
TOTALLY//OUTRAGEOUS AND UNFAIR//IT’S ASHAME HOW THE LAW MAKERS BREAK THEIR OWN LAWS
amerikkka doing what it does best makes laws that they can break when they fill the need to do so. Panther Love
sad sad sad…wishing her the best
Reblog to help her out 4 we both see this is act of racism & hatred. Panther Love
Pingback: Stood Ground And Charged | News Media Source, Entertainment News, Media Source, Celeb News, News Media
I am ashamed that this incident has had very little air play from main stream media. amerikkka the land of the free and imprisoned. Don king said it best only in amerikkka. Bloggers please repost and spread far & wide. Panther Love 4 Eva. I am my brutha’s keeper
http://www.blogtalkradio.com/btrplayer.swf
Reblogged this on innerstanding isness.
Thank u 4 reblogging for alot of support is needed and is greatly appreciated. Panther Love
I am not an attorney, however, on the surface of the story as it is written, it appears you are covered under the “stand your ground” law. It also appears you were decently in conrol of your thinking under such a stressful environment. Is your husband white? Is this a white vs black issue? It surprises me that the total reaction of police and judge were so negative towards you as a female unless there were other issues even though you shot the pistol. I wish you the best and pray to God that you never experience such trauma again. Good luck on your trial.
Both husband and wife are black but he was the one that called the police. Even though he has priors for spousal abuse the courts went by his word and wating 4 the appeal next week.
Pingback: Marissa Alexander Stood Her Ground – No One Was Injured or Murdered – She Faces 25 Years In Prison | Moorbey's Blog | SpootyLinks.com
My heart goes out to her.As a man she did what she had to do
She did what she felt was necessary 4 her survival
Florida just needs to get rid of that law altogether. Too easy to interpret the wrong way or to be used when convenient. Poor woman! She deserves justice!
I have been tweeting and fb’ing this blog post all day! I hope we can help this woman!
This entire situation is messed up. The whiteys love for Blackfolk to kill each other. Had you been a white woman married to a black husband, we would not be having this discussion. i wish you all the best. Where are the Black criminal lawyers in Jacksonville. Johnnie Cochran always did a few cases pro bono. We cannot continue down this evil path of injustice here in America. Some Blackfolk love their massa more than they love themselves. They are not willing to put it all on the line for True black Liberation. This is what I called the conditioned Kneegrow syndrome. Was the victim separated from her husband at the time? Many Black women take these abuser back into their hearts and beds knowing they have a propensity for violent. There is a spiritual lesson to be learned here. I will circulate the situation on social network and Black Liberation websites.
I pray for your innocence to be seen…you did what you needed to protect yourself! I pray things come out great in your appeal. This is just wrong!
This is a horrid series of events that has not granted any justice for the victim. It actually allows her abuser to continue to imprison her, not only physically but emotionally for a long time and he, so far, has had no consequences. Who wins here is the abuse and even though DV is considered illegal, it is a lost battle for so many victims. Myself inculded. After 10 years, still no justice for me. So I hope that things will begin to change for victims of DV annd quickly. Too many people are losing their lives as a result.
Well said
What can be done for Marissa at this point? Send letters to the politicians? She should have shot AT him instead of above him – better outcome, same charges. Been in similar situation & it sucks.
Reblogged this on Blessed and highly Fashionable and commented:
Something has to be done
It is ashme how we expect the law to protect us but it end up felling us. I know a God that want fell you.I will be praying for you my dear. You hold your head up and don’t give up. I say let you go free. Free Marissa Alexander
You are facing 25 years because you deliberately missed him when you shot your gun. Under the “stand your groung law”
you should have shot to kill but your human compassion upon the moment of truth gave him all the time he needed to be
the 1st one to call the police and tell a different story but….. all is not lost….
Send your story to President Obama certified mail and watch what happens.
Sincerely, Enoch Mubarak
President/CEO Mubarak Inter-prizes
http://www.mubarakinter-prizes.com
timeout to everybody commenting on this case because i know everything about the case. the court did not go all by his word. he dropped the charges and the state picked the charges up because she was shooting while kids were in the house. they interviewed all the kids and forensics did their work. she did not stand a chance in court. the jury found her guilty because after the shooting she still went back to him and in their eyes her life couldn’t have been too much in danger. therefore, the police testified against for trespassing which she disabled her own case. now domestic violence is wrong but when you keep going back to a situation like that you’re just as guilty as he is. therefore, stand your ground does not apply to this case, when she went back after the incident and the police told her not too. therefore, you shouldn’t just go by what you read because there is always more to the story than he put on here and always three sides the story, his side, her side and the truth…..BIM!!!!
Juanlier Scott, educate yourself on “learned helplessness”
Hi Mr. Lincoln B. Alexander Jr on behalf of Marissa Alexander: My name is Loretta J., I too was in an abusive martial relationship and know first hand the cruesome cruelity that come with it, the emotional torment, physical scars and mental anguish, please contact me, via email address of lorettabusiness@yahoo.com I’d love to help her out. Please also inform her to not take a jury trial, allow the judge to impose a sentence should one be given its for her own freedom; they’ll the courts, prosecutors and defense will all object, but it’s her human basic right to change her mind, and it’s not too late. This too needs the media attention of the NAACP and it’s community of supporters (like the Travon case) at hand right now.
Signed: someone concerned for her legal rights within the US of A.
I think that you can not use the stand your ground law unless you actually shoot someone or try and shoot them. Instead she fired what my gun instructor called a warning shot. Warning shots are illegal.This is why she may lose this case. Honestly….she should have shot him
what is wrong with the world are you waiting for her to die at the hands of her husband? If it was me I would have done the same thing help her and get some help for her husband.. sad world.. I will pray for you and your husband.. God give you strength to make it thought the storm because you will make it.. this world need to make a change… in everyday.. Why do they make laws? for who ? you know what goes around comes around not just for your husband but for all that has played a part in this crazy mess…
God kept you safe and please pray for strength..Lord hear our prayers..
so sad. praying for marissa.
Pingback: Ms. Parkerazzi
THATS CRAZY AS HELL. SHE STOOD HER GROUND BUT YOU LET THE MAN THAT KILLED TREYVON MARTIN RUN FREE? GOD DONT LIKE UGLY. ALL THOSE THAT ARE INVOLVED IS GOING TO PAY. GOD HAS SOMETHING GREAT IN STORE FOR THIS YOUNG LADY. HANG IN THERE SISTER, DONT GIVE UP, AND DONT GIVE IN. THIS IS THE PERFECT CHANCE FOR GOD TO SHOW HIMSELF.
Are you Kidding me? From experience of living in Florida, and being licenced to carry a gun while on duty, you messed up when you turned and fired the gun as a “warning.” Florida has a strict “no warning shots” law. The military abides by warning shots but not in the civilian world. This was taught in the training. If the gun is fired, deadly force must be used. Shoot to kill with NO and I mean NO regrets. The phrase that pays is “I felt my life and my children’s life was in danger” then BOOM you’re off the hook.
Reblogged this on I am a_cntrovrc.
Respect Komrade 4 picking this up and running with it
If a man will begain with certainties, he shall end in doubts; but if he will be content to begin with doubts, he shall end in certainties.
Wow, that goes to show it’s inside people that could get away with this type of non sense check out Heather Griffin and her boyfriend Manuel A. Guarch, who are Miami-Dade Prosecutors. How does this work for them and not for us. I’d rather take this position any time, because he went and open his on business. Cut, copy, and paste link below to put in search bar to read.
So on your side Marissa Alexander and family you guys should do the petition on change.org for this case to be
http://abovethelaw.com/2011/07/lawyer-of-the-day-georgetown-law-grad-pulls-trigger-may-have-shot-career-in-the-foot/#more-83474
How could I get in contact with you?
moorbey713@yahoo.com
Domestic Abuse Is Everyones Problem: Please Check out this Public Service Announcement, you may beable to help someone today http://youtu.be/rOXP2lRDqx8
why has nobody mentioned the fact that the husband violated the protection order FIRST?!?! its the law’s job to enforce it. they say she is charged with aggravated assault—HE HAD NO RIGHT TO BE THERE IN THE FIRST PLACE! i hope that fact gets much attention because she would not have even had to discharge her weapon had the very real threat not been immediate (and if they say there was no threat, then why was the order granted in the first place?)
MARISSA:
many with issues that need press coverage and a call to action start petitions on CHANGE.ORG, as did Trayvon’s family.
many have been successful in fighting for their cause: http://www.change.org/
For all that she is going through she should have shot the mutha f%cka. This is BS and this country seems to always all of a sudden contradict its laws when it comes to minorities. I bet if she was a white woman none of this would have seen the light of day. My heart goes out to her family because I have been a battered woman and you dont know how your attacker is going to act until the damage is done. Still when you report their azz no one has simpathy they look at you like you asked to be abused. To me thats like saying any form of abuse is deserved thats wrong and so is any person who thinks they can hurt you because you allow them in your heart. My prayers go up for this woman and through God Not this bullsh%t azz justice system her story will prevail.
Pingback: Why Was Marissa Alexander Not Allowed to “Stand Her Ground?” | Dominion of New York
absolutley ridiculious,I pray your Atty is on their job,,my prayers are with you
i dpn’t understand there is a man in same state killed a young man and they trying to help keep him out.she was truly defending herself and she faces 25yrs so they really use that law for who they want. i hope your trial goes okay.
Who is it that I need to write or how can a petition be started to prevent this lady from going to prison? I am not from Florida, but if any of you are, I would like to be pointed in the right direction as to how to help. Please and thank you.
i hope they reopen her case because it doesnt seem right and its unjust plus ive been reading up on Judge Elizabeth Senterfitt and alot of people seem to think she is in the wrong line of work and they dont want her handling a lot of cases. If she doesnt no how to do her job she should quit trying cause she is sorry excuse for a judge any nut case could she that Marissa was trying to defend herself and at that she didnt even hurt anyone.
Praying……………..
This is one of the most asinine cases I’ve ever heard of. This woman was clearly in her own right. Whether she shot him or not. He violated the court “Order of Protection” and came into her home, beat her and was attempting to hold her against her will. If not for her weapon (which was licensed and permitted by the state for her to carry and conceal), she’d probably be dead or beaten so badly that not even her newborn would be able to see her because this man threatened to “Kill” her.
Not sure how they do things in Florida but the entire world can see this is 100% wrong. I can only voice my concerns and share this story. I truly wished there was more I could do to help her. Marissa You and your family and your baby are in my prayers daily for your release totally from this madness. We truly need more people like Marissa to speak up and speak out. We have to get to the heart of the issue and resolve it if there is ever going to be any “justice” because as long as we let them do this and get away with it. We are looking at “Just Us”.
damn that sucks….
prayers going up so that the blessings can come down Marissa
This world is full of hate and if she was white she would never be in prison. The laws and court system is made up by ignorant people and there made to protect the same people. Does any one know he information in prison am sure she need all the support she can get.
I say an online petition should be drawn up in support of this woman and submitted to the authorities. I f we can get several hundred thousand signatures it should make a difference.
I am in full agreement with a petition being drawn up. There is not alot of time she will be in court on Monday
This story is missing a few details. She said she had an injunction against him, but was the injunction signed by her, him, and the police to make it an official injunction? All it takes is for one of the 3 to not sign it and the injunction don’t count. Secondly, what was he doing there? Was he invited by her? Does he live there? If he lives there then an eviction should have accompanied the injunction. An injunction is not an eviction. Whose name is on the deed of the home? Is she in fact the sole home owner?
These details are important, because if the guy was invited to the home by her then it is not a violation of the injunction on his part. If he lives there and there was no eviction made then he has every right to be there when she is not home. An injunction is not an eviction.
Also, her firearms instructor should have made it clear to her that firing a warning shot is illegal.
They were husband and wife living under the same roof. He beat her after just giving birth to a baby girl a couple of days before
Ok to everyone posting about this case, I know all the missing pieces to the case. She convicted her own self and the police testified against her for trespassing after she shot at him. The jury felt her life wasn’t to much in danger since she kept going back. Also that is the reason self defense doesn’t apply to her case. He dropped all the charges but the state picked it up since she was shooting while kids were in the house. They interviewed all the kids including my nephew. She never stood a chance in court because she hurt her own case and tried to get people as witnesses to alter their stories for her. Oh and yes she was staying with him and now he has custody of their daughter and she is just as guilty as he is. I’m not promoting domestic violence but if she kept going back to him in his home than she got what she deserved because the jury said this all could have been avoided had she just stayed away so they could have built a case against him.
I have not heard of this case. This is horrible. When we invite someone into our homes we do so with the expectation of them “behaving appropriately” if someone threatens bodily harm regardless of location we have the right to defend ourselves an I thought the purpose of the SYGL was an additional cushion for those in their homes specifically. If it’s illegal for a spouse to rape a spouse in their home in their SPOUSAL BED then why isn’t it legal for a spouse to protect themselves in the home they share with their spouse if they are in fear for their life. Tenant agreements, deeds, etc… really shouldn’t have anything to do with it. BTW to fire a warning shot is not totally illegal there are previsions wherein firing a warning shot is totally legal and given Marissa was in fear for her life, her husband had made the threat to kill her, there was documented proof of previous abuse not only against Marissa but other women as well. Firing a warning shot is a use of deadly force and can carry the same sentence as if someone was shot IF the threat of great bodily harm or death isn’t imminent.
Panther Love
yes yes, outrage-prayers-etc-etc-etc…what can we do to help? seriously, I’ll repost, mail letters, whatever’s been mentioned. and then who can offer more direct action? honestly, I’m asking sincerely. I want to help this woman.
iF THE COPS DID THEIR JOB THEY WOULD HAVE FOUND THE BULLET IN THE CEILING AND THE LAB SHOULD BE ABLE TO TELL HOW MANY TIMES YOUR GUN WAS FIRED. THEY ALSO SHOULD HAVE TAKEN YOU TO THE HOSPITAL WHICH WOULD HAVE FOUND THE MARKS HE PUT ON YOU.sECOND YOU SHOULD ASK FOR ANOTHER JUDGE TO HEAR YOU CASE BECAUSE YOU FEEL THAT JUDGE IS NOT FOLLOWING THE LAW.
she did the right thing and got punishied wow thats crazy fl law is a joke
I hope she does not go to prison for this. I am beginning to think laws like this are shaped for the benefit of white men, not women and certainly not for people of color. I hope her right to self defense is upheld.
Komrade please repost 4 this not right.
I don’t care whether he lives there or not, no man should ever nput his hands on a woman, just walk away. And this law regarding stand your ground, she stood her ground and is being punished for doing so. Zimmerman claimed the same defense and he was just recently arrested for the murder of Trayvon Martin. So does that mean he was justified in killing trayvon but she is not because she chose not to kill her husband.
Right on family.
That law is not now nor was ever intended for African Americans. It was created to justify the killing of them. New age lynching.
Asante sana. Nor was this law created 4 minorities to use as a defense.
Pingback: Marissa Alexander Stood Her Ground – No One Was Injured or Murdered – She Faces 25 Years In Prison | Moorbey’s Blog « Abel Ashes
This system is messed up because it is ruled by the devil…hes down here with us spiritually and causing alot of trails and tributions for God’s people..Just keep in heavy constant prayer about this situation..Jehovah hears all prays of his childern..He says He will never for sake you..God is just and powerful and justice shall provile in this matter. In the name of Jesus.Amen..
From a concerned,
Jehovah witness
Pingback: Marissa Alexander Stood Her Ground – No One Was Injured or Murdered – She Faces 25 Years In Prison : Federal Jack
Hotep,
Though it has always been that the laws of this “White nation” have been to the detriment of African people. We need to police ourselves, like we did before Europeans inhabited Europe.
This is a bunch of BS. I am so glad I don’t leave in fu*kd up state like Fl.
As a very good friend of mine who carries a badge said, “You Pull It, You Use It”. In my experience, women (some that I know personally) waste too much time warning violent boyfriends/husbands to stay away or else (they will call cops, or they will shoot). I think if Marissa would have killed her attacker she would not be in the situation she is in now… Gave him an out, HE called cops in defense of himself…
She should be free and with her children. This is a gross miscarriage of “law”.
She wasn’t standing her ground. As he was no longer attacking her, her going back inside makes her seem like the aggressor at that point. She says she tried to open the garage but couldn’t due to a mechanical failure. That sounds like the garage door opener was not working…she could have simply pulled the cord and which would have allowed her to easily open it manually. It sounds to me more like she went to the truck to get her gun but she wound up not having the nerve to shoot him and fired in the air. OR she attempted to shoot him but he rushed her which led to her firing toward the ceiling. I have a very hard time believing that you ran to the garage, the garage couldn’t be opened, then you go back inside and fire in the air upon him attempting to charge you. There’s just too much wrong with that story to me. She doesn’t sound like someone who was in fear for her life. Her actions just aren’t consistent with being in fear for your life. Even what she wrote doesn’t paint a picture or fear for one’s life. She used the word “trapped” when she said the garage wouldn’t open. But then she said when she went in he hadn’t left exited through the front door like he was “supposed to”. If she thought he was “supposed to” be leaving, then how did you feel trapped? She was in the garage, how would she have known where he was? She said herself he had come into the kitchen alone (without his son), which means she was aware of who had left and who hadn’t while she was in the garage. Her story sounds like an attempt at justifying what she did (hence why she keeps bringing up his past history). His past history has nothing to do with her going BACK in the house. I just have a hard time believing that someone who is truly in fear for their life, would go BACK in the house. If you truly thought you might die, it would seem to me that you’d find a to get out of that garage. Like I said if she couldn’t open it with the opener she could have pulled the cord and lifted it. Even if it wasn’t quite on the track, there’s a 99% chance she could have opened it enough to squeeze underneath it. This isn’t a case of stand your ground. There was no longer an attack taking place, she wasn’t standing her ground. When she was in the garage, it was over with. She chose to go back inside, though she was supposedly in fear for her life. At that point, it would appear she became the aggressor. I feel sorry for her and what she’s going through, but I can’t say she was simply “standing her ground” because she wasn’t.
ALL WE WANT IS = JUSTICE,JUSTICE, JUSTICE.. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cOnpMhhwejI
I think it’s time and long overdue that we as black people expose the global injustice that we suffers from, a justice system that has never been design to protect people of color. Just like the Trayvon Martin, we have two fatal shootings last month that happened a week apart with two 20 year old black males killed by the hands of new orleans police (NOPD). We as residents are rallying and marching through the streets of the city for justice. So if anyone is near New Orleans this Saturday, we will have a march beginning at 10:00 a.m. by congo square in Louie Armstrong park. Theme: Marching for Justice to Stamp out Injustice.
Stand your Ground don’t apply to Black People didn’t you read the fine print.
Florida is starting to be a place I don’t want to go too.
May Jah bless you, my dear i don’t understand the drastic sentence that has been giving on to you in the process of defending yourself,with all that you have just presented as evidence,but i have many questions in trying to figure out why the evidence did not stand, what was he doing there if you have this restraining order against him,and if you are in such fear of your life why does he has access in your home,did you continue the relationship after he abused you? and was his sons in the same room when the shot was fired in the air? These are the questions that was in my mind in reading the article,if any of my question was yes then you need to rethink the motion that has been ruled against you unfair for not only did you jeopardy the life of the children and if you continue this relationship of any contact then your claim that he is abusive then your rights become rocky i only pray that any of my questions was NO so that you can continue to fight this unfair sentence.
I am a White person tired of being dumped on just because an injustice was done to some black person somewhere. All these posts intimating that white Americans are all kkk makes me sick. You treat us like this and then claim we are the racists? I have never been responsible for a single harm towards anyone black or white and resent these racists remarks. Grow up.
I can’t follow her story very well. “In an unprovoked jealous rage, my husband violently confronted me while using the restroom (how is this possible?). He assaulted me, shoving, strangling and holding me against my will, preventing me from fleeing all while I begged for him to leave (okay again how is this possible if he’s using the restroom? Did he have one hand on his pee pee while peeing in the toilet? or was he holding his pee pee and peeing as he was abusing her?). After a minute or two of trying to escape, I was able to make it to the garage where my truck was parked, but in my haste to leave I realized my keys were missing (Okay, there is a few key things missing here. I gather the truck wasn’t locked). I tried to open the garage but there was a mechanical failure (hmmm…so now all of a sudden there is a mechanical failure and she can’t get the garage open). I was unable to leave, trapped in the dark with no way out (justifying her actions). For protection against further assault I retrieved my weapon; which is registered and I have a concealed weapon permit (hmmm…). Trapped, no phone, I entered back into my home to either leave through another exit or obtain my cell phone ( bam! she found a defense). I don’t buy this story. I’m sorry. Now I think she may have been trying to intimidate her husband and it just turned plain bad.
Okay so let’s sum up this story: Husband is peeing and kicking her ass at the same time. She is pleading for him to leave and then she escapes to the garage and all of a sudden the garage has a mechanical failure so now she is trapped with no where to go which is why she goes back into the house and apparently shoots at the ceiling. Okay, so I don’t know….I’ve been in situations and am also a thinker about how I’m gonna get the hell out without harm or doing harm…all the while I know what I need to do and I do it. In this case it appears that she was thinking about how she was going to intimidate her husband and it backfired.
Sorry to be the odd ball of the crowd…I usually am more critical than others.
Will be posting the court transcpit just as soon as i get them and then we can have it and break it down. For there are many questions that are unanswered.Panther Love
PLEASE GET ALL OF THE FACTS AND DETERMINE WHETHER IT’S A WORTHWHILE CAUSE TO BANDWAGON, OTHERWISE SUFFER LOOKING FOOLISH. I have reviewed the docket for this case including the several domestic violence injunction petitions against both parties, the police reports, the transcript of testimony of the “victim’s” two sons, other filings, along with the verdicts. It’s clear the “victim” was an unsympathetic domestic abuser, but the defendant seems to have issues of her own, which was compounded with an additional charge pending trial (violation of conditions of release with an additional domestic battery charge). It seems the boys’ (her stepsons) testimony contradicted her self defense claims. The father could have coached them but their statement in the initial police report was consistent with the father’s claim. I believe a floor plan layout would help determine whether she had least restrictive means of exiting the hostile situation, although she has no duty to retreat, it may have played a factor in the Stand Your Ground hearing as to the reasonableness of her fear. Alas, the jury must have believed the sons’ version of events which have the parties arguing about the text msg convo w/ her ex-husband from bedroom to the kitchen, defendant slapping and telling the victim, “I can show you better than I can tell you,” then retrieving gun from garage, re-entering the residence and firing into the ceiling before the victim and children ran out of the door. This version of events has the victim moving away from the defendant (not advancing), with his hands up, saying “Please don’t shoot me.” It’s clear the jury bought the victim’s version of events considering they returned the verdict in just 13 minutes!! Unfortunately, she faces a tough minimum mandatory of 20 yrs (I believe) and has no prior criminal background (that I know of). I wonder what her plea offer was prior to trial and if she understood how much she stood to lose from rolling the dice with trial. I get her point that the immunity based on Stand Your Ground has disparate results and is applied unevenly depending on jurisdiction. The problem is the fact finder can choose to believe or disbelieve the facts presented and make credibility determinations of witnesses. Maybe if the firearm was discharged in the presence of the unsympathetic victim alone, there would be more room for mitigation. But when children are placed in the line of fire, a prosecutor’s sympathy for a battered spouse is greatly diminished. I wish her the best on a miracle at 1st DCA b/c despite the verdict, 20 yrs in prison on this verdict is much too stiff…and her newborn shouldn’t have to live without a mother until she’s grown. Very sad indeed and a cautionary tale for all sufferers of domestic violence to seek help, get out, and stay out of abusive relationships! http://www.scribd.com/doc/89763280/Order-Denying-Defendants-Motion-for-Immunity-and-Motion-to-Dismiss
Reblogged this on Juanlier01's Blog and commented:
People need to know more about this case like I do. There is more to this story than he failed to tell y’all. I know a lot about this case and she is just as guilty as the accused. She convicted herself cuz of the truth and she didn’t have no stand your ground case. Also she was trespassing after her life was so called threatened. The police, jurors and judge did their part.
I will pray that judge see your point of view and set you free. God will not enable anything to take place without a good ending. You will truly see a happy ending to this injustice. I pray that the young man freely tell the truth and ease your transition. God bless and good luck with the State of Florida courts and rulings…
Wow this is really sad to hear. I am a white woman and do not like black on black crime or white on white crime or black on white crime or white on black crime. CRIME DOES NOT CARE ABOUT COLOR! This is a circumstance where she had to the right to protect herself. I hope she does not go to jail. Stop the racism!! God is color blind and LOVES us all no matter what color your skin is! Those of us who dont look at skin color should stand up for what is right together not on oppiste sides of the street. I hope everything works out for this girl.
It is increasingly clear to me that our nation’s system is set up for people of color to be oppressed, exploited, shut up and killed. Lord have mercy! This is awful.
This clearly shows the bias and unfairness of the system 1. shes African American 2. female The system sucks and to many of us know it but we can’t stand together long enough to show our solidarity, we all loose in a case like this.
For many they are still deaf,dumb and blind to the truth.Unity in the community
Unfortunately, the Stand Your Ground law was not created to protect a woman, or a person of color. But as the law does not read, “For White Men Only,” it should offer you protection from prosecution. Your life was clearly in danger and you took appropriate legal action. I wish that in the future you always have domestic harmony, and that the state withdraws its unjustified and unjust case against you.
Respect
I guess she didn’t know this law only applies to white males…
So tru…
On the face of it, this woman seem to have been totally within her rights and should never been arrested. But I cant help but wonder if there are parts of the story missing. Mainly: she states that she shot into the ceiling. He states she shot at him. Seems to me that if there is a bullet hole in the ceiling that would make everything pretty cut and dried: in her favor. Maybe she thought she aimed up but didnt quite hit the ceiling, still the question remains, where was the hole??? Surely her defense team has thought of this, I wonder why something so obvious wasnt mentined in the story? Also, she stated that she was abused immediately before the shooting and that’s what caused her to get the gun out. When the police arrived, was she obviously injured? Bruises may not have shown at that point, but was she not cut anywhere? Swollen eye? Broken nose? Lumps where she’d been hit? Something is fishy in Denmark, and I dont think it’s her!
There is proof of the bullet in the ceiling,In the state of fla you firing a warning shot is illegel. Reality is she would nave been better off shooting him.
Hi Bridgit, I thought about the same thing. Her story was sketchy. She said she went to the garage but because she said she ran out to the garage, it would open but there was no way out so she got the gun from the truck, and went back inside..well, why did she go back in? It’s not like the husband pursued her to the garage…If he did then I could see her getting the gun at that point to protect herself…but that was not the case. She got the gun, then realized that she was confined and then went back inside and just started shooting wherever she shot at. I don’t think the police would have arrested her if her story didn’t have so many holes. She is so busy trying to justify herself because she know she is wrong. But whatever. It’s just my take on the situation.
We can disagee to disagree to ge to the truth
I am in agreement with u.
Obviously the “Stand your ground laws” are applicable only for white people! They were never intended for blacks except to become victims of it!
This beautiful lady was in her own home. and this man was not invited in ,he was traspassing. We had to fight like crazy to get the nam arrested who shot and killed a child, but this women get arrested for protecting herself in her own home. next time shoot him and walk away, Lord help us.
This story needs to be on the front page of every newspaper globally. It’s a shame that this case has been handled in the manner that it has so far. It makes it seem like that the law of “stand your ground” is simply a phrase of convience to be applied by an individuals interpretation or feeling of applying this law appropriatedly. And, who gets to decide if the law is applicable are those who either made the law or the DA/prosecuters. However, most of the time these individuals are trying to get case tried and individuals prosecuted on different issues for reputation, promotion, and political agenda. They aren’t concerned with the law being applied fairly or justly. Looking at what happened in the Trayon murder case is a prime example of how the justice system works!!!
Everyone has the right to protect themselves under iminent harm or danger especially when there is a court order of protection in place! If she hadn’t fired a shot which is being referenced as a “warning shot” she’d probably be dead considering his violent history. And, he shouldn’t be allowed around not just her but, he should be allowed anywhere near the children either. Who does that? This woman needs to be set free immediately and she should be compensated for her pain, suffering and the injustice that was served against her! How is it that inidividuals who suffer at the hands of someone are often put in the light as the offender, which to me makes them a victim all over again? This cycle needs to be broken because it creates an atmosphere where crimes are not reported and it gives, the individual who is doing the assaulting a false sense of “hurt anyone and do anything” because you can get away with it!
Thank U Queen
This poor Mother should be released, I dont understand why she would be arrested ir charged, ive been debating this issue the last couple of days, and i have a question, was her garaged an attached garage, some people have said she should have went back “inside” and i have argued you cant go BACK inside if you have not made it outside, do you know if its attached?? Not that it would change my mind that this woman deserves to be let go…..
I will let her know about the feedback that this has received.
Ok soooo, the answer to your question……You should have shot that psychopath right in the heart or in the head. Then there would have been no debate afterward about what happened. I have NO sympathy or mercy for men like this. They have a mentality thats impossible to change. In my experiences, being a victim of their lies, and manipulation can make life hell. When you’re with them, theyre evil and abusive but when you try to get away, or succeed at getting away, they become Satan incarnate. Its about survival, when stuck in a situation such as that, it really becomes a question of ‘Its either him or me’. Dont let me cross his path……..
This hurts my heart. There is very little protection for battered women through the law. Hopefully we can assist in making things change.
Thanks for this. I have put it up on our blog: http://www.outrageradio.com/index.php?/weblog/entry/when_stand_your_ground_doesnt_work/
Michael T
Thank 4 reblogging this injustice 4 this a grassroots effort 4 truth and real freedom
I don’t understand how George Zimmerman who ran down, shot & killed Treyvon Martin was Not arressted for 45 days was covered by the law to protect his home if he felt threathen. Did he only get arrested because of the media? Treyvon was just walking home with candy and a ice tea, this lady husband had documented abuse and they arrested her right away. The Florida government is very confused on their laws, either you have something that’s going to cover the right people not only the white people or nothing at all. She need to be let go.
The media did not jump on this till yesterday and that was because a grassroots effort was started and put into motion
Unbelievable. In the United States we have the right to bear arms as stated in the Second Amendment to the Constitution: “A well regulated militia being necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed” Marissa Alexander was not only threatened with death, she was also physically accosted with bodily harm. If I understand correctly Marissa Alexander also had an active injunction against violence issued against her husband…the aggressor in this case. Come on you political scallywags…get with the program and do the right thing. Marissa Alexander did the perfect thing anyone should do in a case where there life is in extreme danger. She ran…then forced to pick up her weapon…she fired a WARNING shot into the CEILING…which was effective. She saved herself AND HER AGGRESSOR from further harm. Common sense tells me that Marissa Alexander has had her Constitutional rights violated. Let Marissa Alexander out of prison immediately. The Constitution of The United States Of America is rock solid. The States of the United States of America do not have the right to dilute and piecemeal this directive. I am pleading for all citizens of the United States and Florida to contact all political affiliates to the 4th Circuit court and DEMAND a revision. Demand that Marissa Alexander be released from prison. Marissa Alexander deserves the right to transcend the 4th Circuit Court’s mistake. Marissa Alexander, being a citizen of the United States of America has the right to believe in and be upheld by The United States Declaration Of Independence which strongly and bravely states. “We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.”
Shameful is all i could say when this was brung to my attention
I don’t even know what to say. This is so wrong. Now they’re putting mom’s in jail? Further victimizing domestic violence victims? This is not the country I thought it was. Where are we?
amerikkka is not what is says it is or even stand 4…
She states,”I was in the perilous position of leaving an abusive relationship with my husband who has history of violence and documented domestic abuse towards women. Our history included one which required me to place an injunction for protection against violence and was active during the month of August 2010″. An injunction is an equitable remedy in the form of a court order that requires a party to do or refrain from doing specific acts. A party that fails to comply with an injunction faces criminal or civil penalties and may have to pay damages or accept sanctions. In some cases, breaches of injunctions are considered serious criminal offenses that merit arrest and possible prison sentences. Therefore with this said, I am most sure that if there was an injunction then the husband would have been in violation and taken to jail. If there was in fact an injunction then the husband was in violation and should have been arrested and the Stand Your Ground Law 776.013 would apply because it states the following:
1) “A person is presumed to have held a reasonable fear of imminent peril of death or great bodily harm to himself or herself or another when using defensive force that is intended or likely to cause death or great bodily harm to another if:
a) The person against whom the defensive force was used was in the process of unlawfully and forcefully entering, or had unlawfully and forcibly entered, a dwelling, residence, or occupied vehicle, or if that person had removed or was attempting to remove another against that person’s will from the dwelling, residence, or occupied vehicle ( which her husband did not); and
b) The person who uses defensive force knew or had reason to believe that an unlawful and forcible entry or unlawful and forcible act was occurring or had occurred (DID NOT).
2) The presumption set forth in subsection (1) does not apply if:
a. The person against whom the defensive force is used has the right to be in or is a lawful resident of the dwelling, residence, or vehicle, such as an owner, lessee, or titleholder, and there is not an injunction for protection from domestic violence or a written pretrial supervision order of no contact against that person (Therefore the law surely would apply to her if in fact she did have an injunction order against her husband as she stated).
If the police arrived and she told them that she had an injunction against him then she should have provided a copy of the order to the police once they arrived. They also could verify this on the spot and taken the husband to jail. I just can’t see for the life of me why the State of Florida would be act so unjustly towards this woman. Why? Why would the husband call the police on to the scene if he was in the wrong? That’s like calling the police on yourself while committing a robbery. Think about it. If there was an injunction and the husband was beating her as she stated, then surely he would know that he is wrong and would have more than likely got into his car and left for fear of getting into trouble because he is in violation and she could be free. As I have stated, I just don’t see where she is right in her actions and I truly can’t see any reason that the police or the justice system would take sides with a man they don’t even know. All they know is their law and can determine who is in violation of that law and take it to trial.
OMG people. If a person was threatening me with bodily harm… Fight or Flight. Epinephrine (also known as adrenaline) is a hormone and a neurotransmitter.[1] It increases heart rate, constricts blood vessels, dilates air passages and participates in the fight-or-flight response of the sympathetic nervous system.[2] In chemical terms, adrenaline is one of a group of monoamines called the catecholamines. It is produced in some neurons of the central nervous system, and in the chromaffin cells of the adrenal medulla from the amino acids phenylalanine and tyrosine.[3] THINK ABOUT IT…someone INSIDE your peaceful abode..YOUR HOME threatens to kill you. You run (FLIGHT) you cannot escape. With all of these chemicals manifesting in your brain… your thinking is changing… you are driven to survive. Your heart is racing. You know the one thing that will stop this fear is in your home. You have no idea what the aggressor is doing… does he have a gun? does he have a knife, is he harming himself?, is he harming the children? Your mind is going from one thing to the next… looking for a solution. In a split nano second your choice becomes the weapon of choice… your gun…your protection.( FIGHT) which you purchased to protect yourself from harm. You enter YOUR HOME… pick up the gun and shoot INTO THE CEILING. The aggressor leaves. The problem is solved for now. Shooting into the ceiling is known as a warning shot. Marissa Alexander did not aim at her husband. Marissa Alexander aimed at the ceiling. That is not only compassionate but that was brave. Remember Marissa Alexander is experiencing extreme adrenaline symptoms… yet she was able to make a choice to use her weapon wisely. She saved her life and the life of her angry husband.
I believe indeed there is more to this story than what is told here. I wish that people would do a little research before deciding to jump on a bandwagon because someone tells a sad story… I cant see how this woman was even in the position for something like this to happen when he previously put her in the hospital…
Will have court transscripts in the next week or so and will make it into pdf 4 you all that want more info
READ the whole story, but my first question is why did u have sex with him after a protection order, count the months, I won’t get on her bandwagon, don’t play the innocent lady in distress role, she shouldn’t get that much time though, she’ll make it difficult for other battered women to prove self-defense with this bs story of hers
Will have court transcripts in the next week or so and will make it into pdf 4 you all that want more info
Reblogged this on INDIĜENA GAZETARO REVUO.
Asante sana komrade 4 picking this up
Ironically as it may seem, she should have shot her husband. Every firearms instructor teaches his/her student to shot to kill. You never should threaten to shoot anyone, if you’re in fear of your life then shooting them is the only defensible act.
You are right on there! I remember the classes I went to and the instruction was a policemen telling us to shoot to kill. Because if you don’t, they can drag you to prison with their charges again you.
If u shoot to kill then there are no witness’s and by shooting to wound someone now u someone that msy contradict ur story. And then have chares brought against 4 many numorous crimes 1 such is discharging a weapon in the city limits, and a few more that can be used against u
Law says no duty to retreat yet she was arrested for defending herself and not retreating… Pretty horrible when the LAW breaks the law. I have lost all respect for the state government of Florida and all Florida state government agencies and employees. The Florida state government broke the law of Florida. It’s nothing but a hypocrite.
fl figures that they can do what they want to the poor.
That depends on the situation. Some parts of the law only apply to a break-in unless there is an injunction order as she stated. Now, if there was an injunction order in place then the justice system is certainly doing her an injustice. It really isn’t that hard for her to present the injunction order in court when she goes to trial. I’m sure her attorney whether it is a private one or a public defender can produce the injunction order and If she can do this then most certainly she should be released and she should receive compensation for falsely being accused and serving almost a year in a detention center away from her children. Then I can see everyone rallying together to make the justice system work justly.
I think people are on a band wagon here and not really looking at what took place. But from her pitiful plea it almost seems she is being treated unfairly. However, unless her husband is mentally disfunctional I don’t understand why he would call the police on her when he himself is breaking the law by being in the home when he wasn’t supposed to be there.
http://www.scribd.com/doc/89763280/Order-Denying-Defendants-Motion-for-Immunity-and-Motion-to-Dismiss
Motion to dismiss dismissed
http://www.scribd.com/doc/89763280/Order-Denying-Defendants-Motion-for-Immunity-and-Motion-to-Dismiss
Order Denying Defendants Motion for Immunity and Motion to Dismiss for the Marissa Alexander stand your ground case.
America the land of the free if you are a white, protestant male…
so so tru
I guess they would have preferred for to lay down and just let him beat her like a dog…this makes me so sad and furious at the same time.
Right right
I don’t believe Laws pertain to certain color. What I do believe is that the Laws are misinterpreted. Sometimes Laws can contain loopholes. Sometimes, when there isn’t a clear cut and dry understanding of Law you turn to cases to get a resolution or better understanding. I think we as a people are too much in a hurry to cry wolf instead of looking at facts. In the case of Treyvon Martin…it was clear that Zimmerman was wrong I believe that the reason the police hesitate to arrest him was it could have been possible he had signs of being attacked and perhaps since the child was dead and couldn’t tell his side of the story Zimmerman’s story got him off. However, the fact of the 911 call and you can hear the boy screaming for help in the background, the fact that neighbors heard his cry, the fact that Zimmerman was told to stay in his car but chose to get out and pursue Treyvon is by no means worthy of the Stand Your Ground Law. You can’t expect the Law to help you if you yourself are in violation of the Law. Sometimes people don’t understand the laws and automatically assume that they should be allowed to be covered by them. Treyvon’s death wasn’t justified. This woman is trying very hard to justify her actions but from what I can tell by the little I’ve read, she was not is not and will not be covered by the Law unless she can prove that there was an Injunction Order in place. BOTTOM LINE.
As a domestic and sexual violence victim advocate, I and others like me will not let this stand.
thank you
Pingback: Marissa Alexander Stood Her Ground But..... | Unheard Voices Online
Here is the link to the petition site. Only 1,000 a lot more needed 4 it to work http://www.change.org/petitions/free-marissa-alexander#
The unwritten rule is dead men never tell lies. Aim for the middle of the chest and be done with him!
http://eplayer.clipsyndicate.com/embed/iframe?rel=3&windows=1&va_id=3431210&aspect_ratio=3×2&show_title=0&pf_id=9217&auto_start=0&volume=8
wait a minute….this “domestic viiolence injunction” sounds just like a restraining order or protective order. and, it was in effect when she was assaulted? PUHLEASE contact ryan julison! here’s his website: http://julisoncom.com/ he’s the one responsible for getting trayvon martin’s story exposed nationwide (and worldwide). if her story doesn’t get out, an apparent grave injustice will persist.
I HAVE BUT ONE THING TO SAY & THEN YOU THINK ABOUT THE SERIOUSNESS OF DEVISTATION IT IMPLIES ……IF YOU HAVE EYES IM SURE YOU’LLSEE THE SENSE IN WHAT IM SAYING.CLEARLY WE AS A PEOPLE ( BLACK – AFRICAN AMERICAN ) PEOPLE ARE NOT AND WILL NOT EVER BE RESPECTED ON OR FROM ANY HIGHER AUTHORITY LEVEL OF ANY WHITE AUTHORITIVE POWER , FOR THEY CONSTANTLY KEEP SHOWING US ALL OVER THE GLOBE BY THE REPEATINGLY INJUSTICES OF TREATMENT OF OUR PEOPLE NEEDLESS TO SAY IF WE AS A PEOPLE DONT RAISE UP AGAINST THIS SH%!!! AND DEMAND OUR RESPECTFUL RIGHT LONG SIDE EVERYONE ELSE , WE ARE DOOMED CAUSE IF YOU NOTICE THEY KEEP DOING IT TO US WE NEED REPRIBUTION PUNISHMENT SOMETHING HARSH AGAINST THOSE THAT INSIST ON TRYING US ….IT NEEDS TO BE STRONGLY ADRESSED, PROCECUTED, ENFORCED A
BOLISHED ECT…….YOU GET MY AIM IM SURE ,,,,,,UNITY !!!!
All power To The People. Panther Love
So let me get this straight she could have killed that man and not been arrested, but chose to not kill or harm him and now faces 25 years…. and it took over 1 million people signing a petition, the president of the United states to get involved to bring a guilty man to justice for the murder of Trayvon! I am fearful for how society is going. i am praying for you to be found not guilty and return to your children!!!
camilla, the “stand your ground” law was written specifically so that a person who believed they were threatened with serious bodily harm or even death didn’t have a duty to try to flee, but could meet force with force. whether or not she tried to flee the house is irrelevant…under this law. before concluding, however, whether or not she was justified to fire a weapon into the ceiling scaring off the man she claims had intentions of harming her, how about a bit more evidence and fact to justify your conclusion? you stated zimmerman was told to stay in his car, but there is no such record of that. chief lee, before temporarily stepping down, in the early days of this case while defending his department’s conclusion the shooting was in self-defense made the assinine statement that it wasn’t agains the law for zimmerman to follow martin. of course, he conveniently ignored the context of the following (911 tapes), and zimmeman apparently going out of his way to “shadow” or “find” martin. make martin a white 17-y/o white female, and zimmerman a 28 y/o black man…and only a naive mind, or a dishonest one wouldn’t believe the black man had sinister intentions.
nevertheless, one can conjecture, reasonably so, that if a person calls 911, and the operator clearly states or implies in such a way a reasonable person can discern the requested course of action..heed the dispatcher’s. to do otherwise puts a person where zimmerman is right now.
i don’t know the facts of miss alexander’s case…i read her story, but i know no facts. i believe if the family consults with julison communications, they’ll do so with the understanding that if there’s any deception or lies detected with her version of events, she’ll bring a national condemnation upon her…not just local. i’m in 100% agreement with you…if there was an injunctive order against him, and she wasn’t on his property…i’m dumbfounded as to how she could be the aggressor. so, let’s hope if there’s a grave injustice, this story becomes national news….it should be the case with any such circumstances, race notwithstanding.
http://www.ohioverticals.com/blogs/akron_law_cafe/2012/04/florida-cases-interpreting-section-776-041-person-who-initially-provoked-incident-may-not-claim-self-defense/comment-page-1/#comment-13370
Reblogged this on Bougie Black Girl and commented:
Will you stand your ground for Marrisa Alexander. Will you march for her!!!
is stand your ground law only for white people that shoot, sure sounds like it, this is nonesense, it makes me think that the powers that be are all mad, and for a judge to say she could have left out of a window or door, would the stupid judge have walked by someone that has just pinned her, choked her, let alone the fact she was a new mother. too bad if he is the dad, cause now she has to deal with the abuser forever!!!
Reblogged this on beautifulprogressiveminds.
Thanks 4 your support
This story really makes you sit back and wonder how can someone go to jail for protecting themself. Florida is one state that through my eyes make there rules to fit how they fell that day. The people who need to be behind bars are free and inocent people are being charged to make it look like they are working. I am so sorry that you as a Black woman had to go through with being beaten at the ahnds of a man that claimed to love you. I hope that they will see in the end that you were thinkig of yourself and ready to stop the abuse. Th judge should be made to go to a battered womens meeting and just sit in and hear how these me really are then maybe she will understand the hardship of these relationships. I was once a battered woman and I thank GOd that I survived with my life. My heart goes out to you my sister. just keep praying things will get better.
I don’t understsnd why everything has to be about race a bad law is a bad law… an abuser, black, white,green or purple is still an abuser and unfortunately victims are still victims.
I wonder sometimes if the injustice isn’t more against women in general vs. a specific skin color.
Everything is her word against his and sometimes, especially in small towns, his words always win because of the good ole boys club and trust me…. Every.race has one of those.
We need to petition the GOVERNOR AND PRESIDENT for a pardon. Too many of our Brothers and Sisters are rotting in jail while we just sit there and wait on someone else to help.
Having seen so many men get railroaded on so called domestic violence allegations where no shots were fired at all –the men purportedly made terroristic threats–I don’t know what to make of the story. Assuming arguendo that the story as told is true, I wonder how many of the respondents to the story would be as outraged at the story of a man who was sentenced to life for killing his ex-wife even though no body was found. The evidence being that she filed a domestic violence report a few years before. How about a man who spent 9-years in prison because his then 37-year old daughter alleged that she was sexually molested as a child based on “memory recall” evidence only to have the story be proven false. As much as thee natural inclination is to feel sorry for the woman in this story, I wish the readers would be equally outraged at the overwhelmingly disproportionate number of men who are incarcerated on the basis of no evidence at all. At least there is circumstantial evidence against the woman in this case.
This is an outrage, and my feelings about Angela Corey have changed because of her disregard for this woman’s rights. How can she support the family of Trayvon Martin and not support Marissa Alexander? It’s not right! I’ve posted this story twice on my Facebook profile and will continue to post it until someone listens and the community comes together for her support as well as the Martins.
Thank you 4 your support
Pingback: Baisden Rewind: New State of Emergency
Pingback: The Black Man’s Top 10 of the Week
My heart hurts for you but, all things happen for a reason. If you were free would he end up killing you? I believe God places us where he needs us and he will protect us so, listen for the still small voice, you are safe right now. With love and hope.
Marissa, if the prosecutors deemed that you held a weapon without intent to harm someone, (if that was your charge), it is evident that the prosecution has gone too far in trying to make you a punishable victim because you had the gun and therefore they decided to let you prove you way out of this charge because it would be easier to prosecute you than your husband because of the gun. That’s likely the way they looked at it. This whole situation, to me, is a testament to A SITUATION GONE TOO FAR! In all you mentioned, you should have never had to stand your ground. Those entrusted to uphold the law in times act too slowly in metting out justice and protection. As a result, you took matters into your own hands when you felt you had taken all that you could have. As you move through your struggle, think of the scripture that says, “Do not give up in doing what is fine for in due season you shall reap, if you do not tire out!” Stay strong.
Chris
To me it doesn’t sound like a warning shot at all, it sounds like she was afraid and turned her head to shot “AT” him in fear. Like closing your eyes when you jump, there was no warning she shot to defend herself, and was shooting at him, it’s not her fault she missed!
Oh my sister i feel your pain.I and my kids are survivors of domestic abuse too. In 2002 my husband who was a violent drinker, bullied, beat, kicked my oldest son, his step son, in the middle of the night in a drunkin rage, as i slept. whan i woke up and went down and i saw my son I immediately knew something was wrong there was something wierd about my 8 yearold face. so i asked him .He told me in the middle of the night he peed his bed and my husband in a rage took it personally snatched my child up kicked him down the stairs throwing his soiled bedding at him as it went on he berrated humiliated my child kicked him slapped him and chocked out to the field where the clothes line was and made him hang his bedding up. after my son went through all that my husband stil slapped him in the back the head and kicked in the back all the way back to the house where my son retreated and cried himself to sleep. i immediately told him and his sister to go to the car as i ran upstairs to retrieve my sleeping baby. i saw him sprawled out naked on my bed passed out . I wanted to kill him right there and if my priority wasn’t to get my son to safety i might have. i took the kids to the local battered womens office where i reported the incident and called the police and preesed charges nd had him arrest for child abuse right then. so off he went to jail. while he was gone, i got a phone call from the district attorney’s aide or leagal assistant informing me they were charging me with neglect and child deprivation. i was stunned and needless to say gave her the what for and dared her to do that because i did everything to protect him once i was aware.they dropped the charges on me. i moved to town to a new home where i gave birth to my 4th child our 2nd. when he was convicted on child abuse, he was released orders that he is not to cohabitate or event be in the facinity of my older kids…..but gave him visitation to his children…..he continuely pushed the boundries and soon was manipulating his way closer and closer to our home life. refusing to let me and the kids go… and still drinking….he came over one night (not suppose to, a 3rd party was to be the pick up and drop off person) he kept bending the rules. he was completely intoxocated demanding to see his kids he worked his way in and i was scared i knew this was going to go on as long as we were reachable and i was exhausted. he drank took all my zanex and sleeping meds and passed out on my bed i put the kids to bed and went in to wake him to leave and he shot out of the bed and came after be…..he beat me choked me kicked me and battered me. my 2 older kids woke and came to my rescue my 7-9yr old at this time. when the children came to the kitchen i was pretty bruised up and he was standing on my throaght has my children begged for him to let me go, and my daughter cried out “please @$*&#$ please stop leave her alone your killing my mommy, just leave please.” and it just inferiated him more and he just hurt me more. hearing her i somehow got the strength and reached up grabbed his nuts twisted and pulled till he crashed to his knees. i screamed for the kids to get out but they refused to leave me and thier little sister and brother my only thought was to run down to the store about 5 blocks away and call the police cuz he had ripped the phone out of the wall already so i rn as fast as i could got to the store told the clerk my addres to send the police that i was beatin and my kids were there with him and i was terrified that i return and they would all be dead. i ran home and thank god he was gone and my four kids were huddled in the living room crying….he was eventually he was arrested and order no contact. i was given a 99 year restraining order because of the shear violence of the attack on me and my son. there was no precedent in the state for such an order ever. and hey were gonna release him with visitation once again with his 2 kids….when i heard that i knew he was never going to leave us alone so last day of school was friday 2 days away i raised $1000, packed what was important in my truck and one horse trailor put my 2 babies and my 2 children in the car and pulled out of town the next day sat at noon to head across the country to nothing i had family in cal but noone real that could take me andmy 4 kids i didn’t know where i was to rest at the end. after 3 days i cme throught tahoe and almost to sacramento when i was informed a cousin i had never met would give us her living room till we could figure it out. so thats what we did i had a place 2 hours before our arrival. Thank the Lord, i tell you this story because i was almost arrest and charge i had a judge that understood the danger but still was making me be open to his control by allowing visitation of his 2 kids we had. I fled against the advice of the state, judge, and my lawyer but i knew it wasn’t going to end. i had no choice but to flee. otherwise i would kill him or worse he’d kill us. i read your story and feel so sad for you situation. i know what its like to be in complete fear and trapped….i feel like a lucky one in comparison to what you are dealing with. It is a complete miscarriage of justice and a travisty. i will scream to the mountains i will yell and fight for your immediate release. I there is anything i can do to help let me know pleasemy children 10 years later are still affected as i am with PTSD it profoundly devistated the three of us and we are stiil healing as for my 2 kids with him they do not know him or remember him. he sends gifts, thanx to his girlfriend on x-mas and b-days but no real effort to stay in contact regularly by phone. me and my 2 older ones have made a point to not give them any details about what thier father did but to say daddy was sick and hurt me and my son and i had to leave to protect everyone, that thier dad loves them very much and we are and they are content with that. im affraid if i would had listen to them i would be facing a similiar outcome as you….this is not fair or ok in anyones right mind…. my sister stay strong and focused we will be praying for now and am willing to do anything to help you reunite with your family im so sorry you must be victimized again. You are a precious gift and i will not stop til you are free. God bless you and your team. please tell me what more i can do please!!!! im here i have survived!!!!!!
Reblogged this on Faktensucher.
The part of the story everyone is missing is this. Marrisa was issued had a restraining order. Once you have a restraining order taken out on you, you are not allow to come into contact with the person who took it out on you. The only person who can allow contact is a judge, and the proper paperwork must be submitted and heard in court. The only time contact is allow is for the purpose of counseling sessions and very limited other reasons. Marrisa was released from jail, with the conditiion she did not attempt to contact her husband. And also at that time, Marrisa and her husband were living in seperate homes, he lived in the house, she lived in an apartment. Once Marrisa went to see her husband, no matter if he had asked her to, she automatically violated her bond order and restraining order.
Be that as it may, no matter what the circumstances, a person has the right to self defense. Even if she was married to him, living with him and no restraining order at all! It should make no difference. How many people murder their spouses right in their own beds unsuspecting? Allot. If all of a sudden I found that my husband wanted to kill me, when I never believed he would go that far, and he was coming at me, I would shoot him and I would NOT miss!
To many women are in prison because of actually doing this and the reason being saying, “OH, she could have left him.” What a stupid excuse to lock up a person for self defense. She could have gotten away. Ya right!!! Many women are murdered by their men for trying and a restraining order does not stop a mad man. The grave yards of full of these women! The prisons are full of women who tried to her man from putting her there.
We do not have a fair world.
I am in full agreement with u. Right is right and wrong is wrong. Marissa got the short end of the stick even tho she lived in the state of fla and florida has stand ur ground laws on it’s books ,reality check she is and always will be a person of colour and true be told all cases where stand ur ground should have been used it is up to the prosecuting attorney to make that decision. Angela Cory has had a couple of others stand ur ground law cases come before her and she allowed the law to stand but let me make this clear these where white male and in 2 of the cases under less than righteous circumstances..
Wow. This is not fair. I know a woman (a friend of mine) who actually shot her abusive boyfriend that she had lived with for several years and of (whom she had a restraining order against) in the heart while being attacked in the middle of the night and she got away with in being SELF DEFENSE. He lived. She did not face charges in the State of Oregon. She has the right to save her own life. You had the right to save yours and we all should have that right. What is our country coming to when we will be locked up for self defense? Its a country I no longer respect. And to think they are also trying to take our 2nd amendment away ….our self defense weapons away from us so we wont have a chance against attackers. We will also be more vulnerable to rape, Burglaries, you name it. There will not be enough law enforcement’s to do any good for the common person once the attack is actually happening.
U are so right. The government has been trying to disarm it’s citizen’s 4 some time now and it will happen unless people wake up and smell the coffee.
Pingback: UNLESS WE FORGET HER! MARISSA ALEXANDER DID NOT SHOOT OR KILL ANYONE! « www.humansinshadow.wordpress.com
this tells me that the law was not made for us, but made to bury us.
Amerikkka does not make lawz to protect Nu-Afrikan people nor and especially not our babiez…It is my duty and a way of paying respect to my ancestorz & parentz 4 giving to me the wisdom & knowledge of the ancestorz to share at this site and otherz that i run and collaborate with.Even if it makez me an enemy of the state than so be it. The truth must be told